Marvel lab for JTI SSI · 300 AI-moderated biometric interviews · Japan · Italy · Poland · 100 each

Smokers already protect the people they love from their smoke. Nobody owns that space yet. Ploom can claim it. Five decisions get you there.

01101/300
JP40
IT34
PL27

Lead with Concept A.

101 of 300 ranked it first

0212 → 95%
Without label12%
With explanation≈95%

Label WE mode and explain it.

Give the feature a meaning

03?
Reduction___ %Evidence still needed

Prove the reduction.

Quantified claims, not a promise

0482%
Nova 82Atom 18

of every 100 people

Launch Nova.

246 chose Nova; 54 chose Atom

055/100

5 willing · 95 not willing

Rethink Poland’s price.

199 zł (≈$50) is the barrier

Japann=100 · 91 completed · 56 min

50 Soloists · 50 Dualists

Italyn=100 · 90 completed · 65 min

50 Soloists · 50 Dualists

Polandn=100 · 89 completed · 81 min

50 Soloists · 50 Dualists

Soloists = heated tobacco only · Dualists = heated tobacco + cigarettes · 270 of 300 completed every module · fieldwork 31 Oct → 19 Nov 2026

The short version · 2 minutes

Smokers already protect the people they love from their smoke.

They leave the table, open the window, change the jacket. Nobody told them to. Ploom ME/WE is built for exactly that, and almost nobody can tell: only 36 of 300 understand what WE means.

That's a labelling failure, and the cheapest problem in this report to fix.

01Leave the table
02Open the window
03Change the jacket

What we found · hover any card for the detail

3/3markets

The story wins everywhere.

Concept A is first in Japan, Italy and Poland. It lands when it names a partner, a child or a parent, and dies the moment it mentions guilt or “society”.

hover for more ↑
78of 300

The label sells the wrong thing.

They hear WE as “share my device”, then picture someone else's mouth on it. In Poland it's 40 of 100.

hover for more ↑
?no answer yet

A claim without a number isn't believed.

The first question is always “how much less?”. Today there is no answer.

hover for more ↑
82%about 8 in 10

Nova is the product. Atom is the discount.

246 of 300 pick Nova, mostly on looks. The story leads, the hardware follows.

hover for more ↑
5of 100 Poles

Poland is priced out.

Only 5 in 100 would pay 199 zł (≈$50) for Nova. The median is 115 zł (≈$29).

hover for more ↑
€29vs €45 median

Italy is priced too low, Japan's gap too small.

Atom at €29 (≈$31) against a €45 (≈$49) median makes people doubt the quality.

hover for more ↑
0say less “for me”

The brand already moved.

214 of 300 say Ploom feels more “for me” after one conversation. None say less.

hover for more ↑
Basis

300 interviews, 100 per market. The signal is the same in all three.

Don't stop here

Six things that break the brief, and all the evidence behind every number.

Keep reading →
So now what

The product is right and the story is right. Three details are wrong, all fixable before launch.

1

Label WE.

“Less smoke and smell around others” on the device, the pack and every ad.

hover for more ↑
2

Prove it.

Test the claims and launch with a number.

hover for more ↑
3

Fix the prices.

Bundle Nova at 199 zł (≈$50) in Poland and widen the Atom gap in Japan.

hover for more ↑

Still open from the brief: which claim people believe, and whether Atom's seven colours change the choice. Until tested, every claim and both device names are educated guesses.

What you didn't expect

Six things that break the brief.

“Nothing”
comes to mind

when asked about a bad moment. Then they describe moving away, refraining and masking all the time. The need is huge and completely invisible to them, so copy has to name the behaviour, not ask about the problem.

78
of 300 think WE = sharing

the device with someone else. In Poland it's 40 of 100. The immediate follow-up is disgust: “I'd prefer the other person didn't put their mouth where I smoke.” The hero feature, unlabelled, is a hygiene objection.

61%
of Poles prefer the name “Atom”

…while choosing the Nova device 72 to 28. The name and the product are pulling apart, so whichever name wins, Poland launches with a mismatch.

82%
of Italians would pay more for Atom

than the €29 (≈$31) asked. Some found it so cheap it raised quality doubts. Median WTP is €45 (≈$49): the price is leaving money and credibility on the table.

5%
of Poles would pay 199 zł (≈$50) for Nova

Median WTP is 115 zł (≈$29) and 85 of 100 call it too high. “200 zł (≈$50)? Are you kidding?” At this price, Poland doesn't launch.

0
said Ploom feels less “for me”

214 of 300 say it feels more. Just talking about consideration for 60 minutes moved the brand, before any advertising existed.

The seven findings, one line each
  1. 01Consideration for loved ones wins.Concept A is ranked first by 101 of 300 and last by only 18, and still leads after correcting for show order. The winning frame is protecting a partner, child or parent, not “society”. Abstract audiences don't move anyone.
  2. 02“WE” doesn't explain itself, and the wrong reading is a hygiene objection.Unaided, only 36 of 300 got the intended meaning. 78 read it as a mode for sharing the device with someone else (40 of 100 in Poland) and immediately worried about someone else's mouth on it. 59 couldn't interpret it at all. Unlabelled, WE sells the one thing nobody wants.
  3. 03Don't frame them as guilty, judged or missing out.They recognise the behaviours (opening windows, leaving the table) but reject the self-image. “I'm not judged, I just don't want to bother anyone.” Accusation copy will be tuned out.
  4. 04A mode can't change where smoking is allowed.Wherever copy implies staying at the table or smoking “freely”, credibility collapses on the spot. One impossible promise discredits the whole device.
  5. 05Credibility depends on proof.Two modes feel plausible. Then comes “how much less?”. Without a number, a non-smoker's verdict or a trial, the claim stays a slogan.
  6. 06Nova wins on looks, not features.Seven colours, slimmer shape, screen and Smart Pause. Atom reads as “like the current IQOS/Ploom”, so it inherits no excitement and no reason to switch.
  7. 07Poland is the pricing outlier.Polish median willingness to pay for Nova is 115 zł (≈$29) vs 199 zł (≈$50) asked. In Japan, Atom's ¥1,000 (≈$7) gap feels too small to justify fewer colours and functions.
Exhibit 1The why · consumer tension

Smokers already self-police. They just don't call it a problem.

01Move away

from tables, children, non-smoking friends

02Refrain or shorten

when someone might mind

03Make others wait

while finding a smoking area (申し訳ない in Japan)

04Mask

deodoriser, perfume, gargling, a jacket change

Japan
Designated areas, unfamiliar places, clients, the izakaya table.
Italy
Partner, parents and friends commenting on odour; children; cars.
Poland
Leaving parties and family gatherings, balconies, office exits, tram stops.
Everywhere
Battery and charging is the top product complaint, ahead of anything about smoke or smell.
Exhibit 2ME/WE comprehension

Only 12% read “WE” as intended without help.

All 300 people · unaided understanding
What WE meant to themn=300
= 1 respondentAll responses
Japann=100
2337171013
Italyn=100
331211431
Polandn=100
103040515
Alln=300
3698782959
“ME is set up for one user, and WE is for when several people use it.”
— Poland · heated tobacco
“I'd prefer the other person didn't put their mouth where I smoke.”
— Italy · dual user
Exhibit 3Concepts · 5 tested, rotated order

“Considerate” wins in every market. 1 in 3 rank it #1.

Where each concept sits · tap one
During useAfter useMeOthers

Circle area reflects first-choice votes. Position is a qualitative mapping.

#1 picks of 300 · mean rank (1 = best)
Wins

A · Considerate

“Your moment. Your choice. Ploom.”

Mean rank · 1 is best1 → 5
Japan2.18Italy2.19Poland2.44

Mean rank by market · last for 18 · vs. slot −0.37 · benefit 3.9/5

“I'm not the only one living in Japan, so I have to think about the people around me, at least a little.”
— Japan · heated tobacco
Works
Lands as an everyday truth: holding back, moving away, asking permission. Almost nobody calls it exaggerated, because it describes what they already do.
Fails
Smokers who already only use designated areas (mostly Japan) feel it isn't about them. A few reject “guilt”: “it's respect, not guilt”.
Fix
Swap guilt for consideration and name the people: partner, kids, parents. In Japan add the meiwaku angle, the social debt of bothering others.
Segment shifts · 150 each · 50 per market
Soloistsn=150
TopA · Considerate2.31
SecondB · Missing out2.95
BottomD · Social judgement3.55
1 · best5 · worst
Dualistsn=150
TopA · Considerate2.23
SecondC · Planning & restrictions3.06
BottomD · Social judgement3.29
1 · best5 · worst
Exhibit 4Devices & names

82% choose Nova for its looks, not its features.

Nova100 respondents per marketAtom
Japan81 / 19
81%
19%
Italy93 / 7
93%
7%
Poland72 / 28
72%
28%
Name vs device

Nova name wins 181–119 overall. But Poland picks the Atom name 61–39.

Nova

7 colours, slimmer, screen, Smart Pause. Reads: new, innovation, supernova; a few say feminine.

Atom

“Like the current IQOS/Ploom”. The name reads as compact, but also “atomic bomb” and Astro Boy.

Exhibit 5Pricing · stated WTP before price shown · USD at ¥150, €1 = $1.08, 1 zł = $0.25

Poland is the price problem: 85% say Nova at 199 zł (≈$50) is too high.

Where price meets willingness to pay

USD · median and stated range · 100 people per market

Stated WTP rangeMedian WTPAsked price
JapanNova
−$1 vs median
$27$27
JapanAtom
−$1 vs median
$21$20
ItalyNova
+$3 vs median
$50$53
ItalyAtom
−$17 vs median
$49$31
PolandNova
+$21 vs median
$29$50
PolandAtom
−$4 vs median
$29$25
$0$20$40$60$80$100

Above: median willingness to pay. Below: asked price. Approximate USD conversions; not an optimised launch-price model.

Atom vs Nova · the price step, in USD
Japan−25%
Nova$27
Atom$20

Saves ≈$7. Too little for fewer features.

Italy−41%
Nova$53
Atom$31

Saves ≈$22.

Poland−50%
Nova$50
Atom$25

Saves ≈$25.

What people said at the asked price
Good valueFairToo high

Japan

Nova · asked¥3,980≈$27

Median WTP ¥4,100 (≈$27) · range ¥2,400–¥9,100 (≈$16–$61)

481537

48 / 15 / 37 · 53 of 100 would already pay it

Atom · asked¥2,980≈$20

Median WTP ¥3,150 (≈$21) · range ¥1,600–¥5,800 (≈$11–$39)

472132

47 / 21 / 32 · 54 of 100 would already pay it

Nova lands exactly on median WTP. Atom is the problem: “only a ¥1,000 (≈$7) difference” for fewer colours and functions, so it reads as a bad deal rather than a cheap one.

Italy

Nova · asked€49≈$53

Median WTP €46 (≈$50) · range €26–€91 (≈$28–$98)

303040

30 / 30 / 40 · 46 of 100 would already pay it

Atom · asked€29≈$31

Median WTP €45 (≈$49) · range €22–€78 (≈$24–$84)

77149

77 / 14 / 9 · 82 of 100 would already pay it

Comfortable. Only 9 of 100 called Atom expensive. The risk runs the other way: some found €29 (≈$31) so low it raised quality doubts.

Poland

Outlier
Nova · asked199 zł≈$50

Median WTP 115 zł (≈$29) · range 70 zł–225 zł (≈$18–$56)

1385

2 / 13 / 85 · 5 of 100 would already pay it

Atom · asked99 zł≈$25

Median WTP 115 zł (≈$29) · range 60 zł–260 zł (≈$15–$65)

593011

59 / 30 / 11 · 71 of 100 would already pay it

Anchors split: Ploom Aura (200–300 zł (≈$75)) vs promo devices (50–110 zł (≈$28)), and 199 zł (≈$50) lands on the wrong side of both. “200 zł (≈$50)? Are you kidding?” Bundles came up unprompted.

Exhibit 6Brand

71% say Ploom now feels more “for me”. Nobody says less.

Japan42 same · 0 lessItaly13 same · 0 lessPoland31 same · 0 less
behind the competition→cares about me and others
one of many→innovator
an option→the choice
“It was an option; today it's the choice. If IQOS is a Panda, Ploom is a Ferrari.”
— Italy
Exhibit 7The interview arc · Tacit Tech K/S/I scores per step

Concept A peaks at 78.5 sentiment. The devices cool the room: Atom drops to 51.3, and the price only partly wins it back.

SentimentInterestCongruence

Sentiment

78.5 / 100

Interest

80.8 / 100

Congruence

27.1 / 100

Concept AAll markets · equal weights
CONCEPTS & RANKINGDEVICES & PRICE0255075100CONGRUENCE · SEPARATE ZOOMED SCALE (20–35)20253035ABCDERankingNovaAtomNova + $Atom + $

Concept A · Claim

“Your moment. Your choice.” Consideration for the people you love.

Concept A, #1 in every market

Tacit Tech AI scores, 0–100: S = sentiment, I = interest, K = congruence (dashed line in its own track, zoomed scale of 20–35). Steps follow the interview: five concepts, the ranking, both devices without price, then with price. Values are the source synthesis scores, with the three markets weighted equally (100 each).

So now what

Eight moves, in order.

  1. 1

    Lead with A, name loved ones

    Partner, children, parents. Replace “guilt” with consideration. Keep “Your moment. Your choice.”, re-translated for Japan with the meiwaku angle.

  2. 2

    Give WE a descriptor, always

    On device, pack and copy: “less smoke & smell for people around you”. Without it, 1 in 4 hears “share your device” and thinks hygiene, especially in Poland.

  3. 3

    Prove the reduction

    A quantified claim, a non-smoker's verdict and a trial mechanic. It's the single most requested thing, and the only thing standing between interest and belief.

  4. 4

    Never imply WE beats the rules

    Drop “more freedom”, “planning” and anything suggesting staying indoors. One impossible promise discredits the whole device.

  5. 5

    Retire judgement (D)

    Keep its observed cues (the opened window, the moved chair) as proof points inside A, where they read as consideration, not accusation.

  6. 6

    Point E at cigarette converts

    For them smell is the most concrete benefit. For HT users, reframe around room, car and breath.

  7. 7

    Make Nova the hero

    Lead with colours and Smart Pause. Widen Atom's gap in Japan. Consider a 199 zł (≈$50) launch bundle in Poland, where only 5 of 100 would pay the ask.

  8. 8

    Test claims & names next

    Claims were out of scope; neither device name signals the modes, and Poland prefers the Atom name while choosing the Nova device.

Exhibit 7Not answered yet · vs. the research brief

Two questions from the brief are still open.

Open

Which claims maximise relevance, credibility and believability?

Step 4 of the brief. Claims were out of scope in fieldwork. What we know: people ask “how much less?” and want numbers, a non-smoker's verdict or a trial. Until that's tested, every claim is a guess.

Open

Do Atom's 7 expanded colours change preference?

Not tested. What we know: Nova's 7 colours are its #1 driver, so colour range is proven to move choice. If Atom's range lands the same way, the device gap could narrow fast.

Answered: smoke & smell struggles (Exhibit 1), the 5 concepts and the ME/WE model (2–3), devices, pricing and names (4–5).

Who we interviewed · recruitment criteria

300 heated tobacco users. 50 soloists and 50 dualists per market.

HT Soloists · 150

Ploom, IQOS or glo users who do not smoke cigarettes. Purity check: no cigarette use in the last 30 days. Soft brand quotas so no device dominates.

HT Dualists · 150

Ploom, IQOS or glo users who also smoke regular cigarettes. Heated tobacco vs. cigarette share of daily use captured at screening.

Age & gender

Men and women, legal age +1 up to 55: Japan 21–55, Italy 19–55, Poland 19–55. Soft quotas for a balanced spread.

Device & stick variant

Mix of Ploom, IQOS and glo. Current stick variant (tobacco, menthol, flavoured) recorded. Soft quotas per market.

Everyone

At least 6 sticks or cigarettes a day. Buys their own. Lives in the market. Interviewed in Japanese, Italian or Polish.

Interview

90-minute AI-moderated depth interview, online, in the local language. About 15% replacement buffer for no-shows.

Source: Marvel Lab JP/IT/PL proposal v3.1, recruitment criteria (screener and market feasibility).

Raw data · for analysts & AI

Run your own analysis.

n=100 per market: 50 soloists (heated tobacco only) and 50 dualists (heated tobacco and regular cigarettes). One row per respondent, with profile, ranks, benefit scores, WE reading, device, price, brand and K/S/I scores.